©2014-2023 Penscott Management Corporation. All rights not expressly granted herein are reserved. The APO E Gene Online Program™ and the APO E Gene Program™ are part of the APO E Gene Diet®, which is a registered trademark of Penscott Corporation.
Information on this website is intended for informational purposes and is not a substitute for medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Learn more.
Collagen, often hailed as the fountain of youth for its role in skin elasticity and joint health, has recently gained significant popularity as a dietary supplement. As with all wellness trends, it's essential to take a closer look to understand potential drawbacks. While collagen supplements offer benefits for many, be aware of scenarios where collagen supplements might not be suitable or even carry risks.
Allergic Reactions and Sensitivities
Some collagen supplements are sourced from animals—particularly marine and bovine sources. Individuals with allergies to seafood or specific animals could be at risk of allergic reactions or sensitivities when consuming collagen derived from these sources. It's crucial to carefully read labels and consult a healthcare professional if you have known allergies.
Risk of Contaminants
The sourcing and production of collagen supplements can vary. Poorly regulated manufacturing processes may lead to contamination with harmful substances, such as sprays and chemicals, heavy metals, or toxins.
Collagen supplements are often derived from animal connective tissues, which can be challenging to digest for some individuals. Digestive issues, such as bloating, gas, or discomfort, may arise, especially in those with sensitive stomachs or gastrointestinal conditions.
Collagen supplements may interact with certain medications or other supplements. Individuals using blood-thinning medications or those with underlying health conditions should be very careful and speak with your provider first before adding collagen to their regimen to avoid adverse effects or unwanted interactions.
While collagen supplements are marketed for various benefits, scientific evidence supporting some of these claims is limited. Claims related to anti-aging, skin health, and joint repair should be approached with caution, and individuals should manage their expectations.
Unwanted Weight Gain
Some collagen supplements are flavored and sweetened, contributing to additional calorie intake. Overconsumption without accounting for these extra calories could potentially lead to weight gain, particularly if individuals rely solely on collagen supplements for their nutritional needs.
Collagen supplements often derive from animal sources, raising ethical concerns for vegetarians, vegans, and those who prioritize cruelty-free choices. Plant-based alternatives or collagen-promoting foods might be more aligned with their values.
Examples of more thoughtful alternatives:
- Organic hormone free, non GMO chicken and turkey, (Distal Farms)
- homemade bone broth,
- wild fish
- organic egg whites
- citrus fruit
In the quest for enhanced wellness, it's crucial to approach collagen supplements with informed awareness, especially as it relates to a person’s APO E genotype. If you have questions, consider scheduling a consultation with Pam McDonald before adding any new supplement to your APO E gene supplement routine, especially if you have underlying health conditions or specific dietary requirements.
Pamela McDonald FNP
Integrative Medicine Fellow